Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tamara Isaacs Ciocci's avatar

Following these events has been pretty brutal this week. It’s an emotional story. It begins with the shock and horror of 9/11 and going to war in 2 countries, one of which has nothing to do with the hunt for Bin Laden. Afghanistan is complex and filled with anguish and 20 years in with the loss of so many, it’s hard to imagine how this was going to end. The war spans 4 presidencies…yet the coverage has been rife with misinformation. As I read this, filled with the horror of losing our brave men and women this week, I am also reminded of all of those young faces I saw at Parris Island 3 plus years ago when we attended the graduation ceremonies for my son. The women’s battalion impressed me the most. Marine Corp training differed than any other. It is 13 weeks with additional survival training months after. They cover land, air and sea. They must maintain their physical fitness throughout their service as first responders. The young men and women were lovely and meeting each graduate was an honor. It hits hard when you get the privilege to witness these ceremonial graduations. They take young people as 18 year olds and mold them into men and women fit to serve. Even if you don’t support the wars, you are hit with the realization that this form of service is like no other. You become a family. Everyone’s son or daughter is now yours. You worry when they are away and worry when they are home. The loss of these marines this week was like a dagger in our hearts. My son knows of one of them men. They tell you at graduation that these men and women will travel the globe and always know a familiar face from their training programs. It’s true. I have a heavy heart for the families. I have a heavier heart over the horrible coverage that ensued and the political points made out of this withdrawal. I am so grateful that my family is safe but I am devastated by those that lost their loved ones. The callousness of Twitter exemplifies that a majority of people don’t understand that the families at home deserve better…and more respect.

Thank you for your diligence email Filey. Your work here is so valuable to those of us who want facts and not bias. It’s a safe place. It’s all here because you took the time from your busy days to help those of us who want facts. It’s a sacrifice I’m certain of. You are an angel. Sending you my blessings. I have been reading this in parts….my brain is so foggy today. ❤️Tamara

Expand full comment
Marsha's avatar

Thanks for sharing all this info in one spot. I've been pretty upset - pissed - sad about the coverage this past couple of weeks too. But then I remembered I felt the exact same emotions when Bush went from AFGH to Iraq. (I didn't want to go into AFGH but at least I understood why.) Anyway - right before Iraq invasion it was obvious the Bush Admin was lying and the media was gaslighting us. They were so into invading Iraq even Dan Rather admired the "Shock & Awe". None of my friends were as concerned as I. It was lonely. This time the media is still doing their same deference to the war machine & contractors, but my family & friends agree with me. I just stopped watching the people that wanted to keep us there forever. Anyway - when I watched the announcement this afternoon that we were OUT I smiled. I thank God that we are gone & hope that the Taliban fakes being reasonable long enough for us to get Americans, our Afghan Allies and the animals out. War is Over!!

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts